Quilt vs. Comforter:
Differences and Which To Buy

While quilts and comforters can both make cute bedding ideas, they aren’t exactly the same thing. Quilts are thinner textiles made of three layers stitched together in a technique called “quilting.” Comforters, on the other hand, are thicker bed toppers filled with a fluffy layer of down or other insulative material. 

When it comes to quilts vs. comforters, each have their own pros and cons. Knowing the differences can help you make the best choice for your needs and style preferences. So let’s get to it! Here’s what you need to know when shopping for quilts or comforters.

What’s the Difference Between a Quilt and a Comforter?

The main differences between quilts and comforters are their thickness, warmth, look and use. 

Quilts are typically thinner than comforters and not as warm. Because of this, quilts are popularly used to create layered bedding looks by using additional blankets or keeping a quilt at the foot of the bed. You can also use quilts for more than just bedding. People commonly use them as blankets, couch throws or even as wall art. 

On the other hand, comforters are usually thicker and warmer than quilts. This is because comforters use more insulative materials in their inner layers. The additional filling also gives comforters a loftier, fluffier look than quilts. However, because comforters can be more bulky, they aren’t often used as blankets in the rest of the home. You will almost always use comforters simply for bedding.

What Is a Quilt?

A quilt is a decorative textile made up of three layers. The top layer can be a solid fabric or a patchwork of different fabrics. The middle layer contains batting material that gives the quilt its warmth—usually wool, feathers, down or cotton. The third layer is the backing, which is typically a solid fabric. 

When these three layers are stitched together simultaneously, the technique is called “quilting.” Stitching often adds to the quilt’s pattern, like wavy stitch lines set against straight or square fabric patches. Some quilts even feature stitching that looks like hearts, vines or flowers. 

You will commonly use quilts as bedspreads, but you can also use them as blankets or even as wall art. Historically, quilts are made by hand but many modern quilt makers streamline the process with sewing machines.

Pros

• Not usually bulky
• Good for keeping cool
• Good for creating layered looks
• Can give a weighted feeling

Cons

• May not be warm enough for winter
• Doesn’t give a light, cloudlike feeling
• Doesn’t have loft for a soft, fluffy look

What Is a Comforter?

A comforter is a type of bedding that’s made of two fabrics stitched together with a fluffy inner layer for warmth. These layers can be quilted together or stitched with baffle boxing. In baffle box stitching, additional layers of fabric are sewn between the top and bottom layers to provide more space for the inner filling to expand. 

You may be wondering what the difference is between a quilt and a comforter made with a quilting stitch. The main difference is the thickness of the inner insulative layer. Quilts use thinner batting layers, whereas comforters use thicker, fluffier inner layers. Like quilts, these layers can be cottons, wools or downs. 

Comforters are also sometimes confused with duvets. While duvets feature two pieces (an insert and removable fabric cover), comforters come as single piece of bedding.

Pros

• Good for staying warm
• Provides a lofty, fluffy look
• Provides a cloudlike feeling
• Single layer speeds up making the bed

Cons

• Can be bulky
• May be too warm for summer
• Not great for creating layered looks

Should I Get a Quilt or Comforter?

Are you on the fence between getting a quilt or comforter? Here are some of the main considerations that can help tip you in one direction or the other.

• Warmth: Because of their thicker insulative layer, comforters are almost always warmer than quilts. If the weather in your area is very cold, you may want to opt for a comforter. However, if you tend to sleep hot, a quilt may be the more comfortable option.
• Aesthetic: Because quilts tend to be less warm than comforters, they are great for layering. If you’re someone who likes the look of a blanket at the foot of the bed, for example, a quilt could be a great choice. However, if you want a loftier, fluffier look, a comforter is the way to go. Having one layer can also speed up the process of making your bed.
• Sensation: While comforters are thicker and warmer than quilts, they tend to be lighter when it comes to actual weight. If you prefer sleeping under something weighted, you’ll probably prefer a quilt. Comforters, on the other hand, are great for those who want to sleep under something that feels lightweight and fluffy.
• Price: Price can vary widely for both comforters and quilts depending on its materials and construction. Artisanal, handmade quilts will be more expensive than machine-made quilts. Likewise, silk comforters will be more expensive than cotton. When looking at price overall, you may find that comforters are more expensive than quilts because they use more material in their inner layer.
• Care: Like price, how you care for a quilt or comforter will depend on material. That’s why it’s important to look at the care instructions before purchasing to make sure you can keep up on maintenance. Besides looking at material, it’s also important to consider bulk. Some comforters may be too bulky to fit in a home washing machine and may require professional care.

Quilt vs. Comforter: FAQs

Have more questions when it comes to quilts vs. comforters? Here are answers to some of the most commonly asked questions.

Are Quilts Cooler Than Comforters?

Quilts are usually cooler than comforters. This is because comforters tend to have thicker inner layers of insulative materials. This makes quilts a great option for those who tend to sleep hot. However, if you live in a cold climate, quilts may not offer the needed warmth.

Is a Quilt Lighter Than a Comforter?

When talking about actual weight, quilts tend to be heavier than comforters. This is because quilts tend to use heavier weight fabric and fillings than comforters. However, when talking about warmth, comforters are the “heavier,” warmer option.

Is a Comforter the Same as a Duvet?

Comforters are not the same as duvets. A comforter is a single piece of bedding made of two fabrics stitched together with an inner filling. A duvet comes in two pieces: an insert filled with insulative material and a removable fabric cover.

Are Comforters Easier To Wash Than Quilts?

Comforters tend to be harder to wash than quilts. This is because they may be too bulky to fit inside an at-home washer. Because quilts are thinner and less bulky, fitting them inside a washing machine is usually not a problem. 

However, care will depend on the material and construction of each piece. A silk, handmade quilt will need to be dry-cleaned, whereas a cotton comforter can be machine-washed—assuming it fits in your washer.

Should I Buy a Quilt or Comforter for Summer?

Quilts tend to be a cooler option than comforters. So, if you’re looking for an option that won’t make you overheat in the summer, you’ll probably prefer a quilt. 

Whether you opt for a quilt or comforter, you’ll find everything you need in our bedding shop!